Thomas "Tommy Karate" Pitera aka "The Butcher" (born December 2, 1954) is a former Mafia hitman in the Bonanno crime family. Pitera earned a reputation as a vicious and sadistic killer who enjoyed murdering people. He was suspected by law enforcement of as many as 60-200 murders. He was well known for his use of karate and other martial arts when fighting which is a skill he had learned at a young age. It earned Pitera his nickname "Tommy Karate." The FBI and the DEA described Thomas Pitera as a " cold-blooded, homicidal maniac.", "heartless, killing machine", and a "brutal psychopathic killer", FBI Agents and DEA Agents has stated that "Law Enforcement has never encountered the level of brutality and ruthlessness from anyone other than Thomas Pitera, the murders he committed made Law Enforcement sick, Tommy Pitera is a very terrifying and fearsome man, he would kill anybody in a heartbeat, and without hesitation, he's killed women, children, innocent people, his friends, theres nothing he wouldn't do. He scares the scary guys, he puts the fear of god in the scary and ruthless men. Tommy Pitera would chop his victims up into little tiny pieces, he would often torture most of his victims to death, in the most gruesome and evil ways you could possibly think of. Tommy Pitera has killed by setting people on fire, he's killed people with knives, he's killed people with guns, he's killed people by dismemberment, he's killed people with swords, he's killed people with his bare hands, he's killed by poisoning peoples food and drinks with cyanide poisoning, he's killed people by strangulation, he's killed people with grenades, he's killed people with nail bombs, he's killed people with ice picks, he's killed by snapping peoples necks, he's killed by punching people to death, he's killed by drowning people, he's killed people with baseball bats, he's killed people with machetes, he's killed by slitting peoples throats, and he's killed in many other gruesome and ruthless ways. Tommy Pitera was the most feared mobster in New York, during his time. everybody feared Tommy Pitera, he would walk down the street and people quickly got the hell out of his way, people would bite their nails and get the goosebumps when they saw Tommy Pitera walking down the street. The street gangs in New York feared him, the biker gangs in New York feared him, other mobsters feared him, his own associates feared him. Thomas Pitera was literally feared by everyone in New York City. Tommy Pitera was the most vicious and dangerous mobster of his time.
Former NYPD Detective Joseph Coffey stated that "I've never in all my years of being a detective have came across someone so evil, brutal, and ruthless, he makes Ted Bundy and Henry Lee Lucas look tame and gentle. Thomas Pitera is one of the most ruthless, scariest, and dangerous men that the NYPD have ever came across. I personally believe that Tommy Pitera has killed many more than 60 or 100 or even 200 people, i wouldn't be surprised if he's single-handedly murdered hundreds and hundreds of people. If Thomas Pitera isn't the devil than i don't know who or what is. Tommy Pitera is pure evil, he is a complete psychopath, he's a man without a conscience, that would kill absolutely anyone and anybody in a heartbeat, he would kill women, children, innocent people, Tommy Pitera is a cold blooded, ruthless, psychotic killer, he is an absolute lethal madman, and a crazed animal. Tommy Pitera wouldn't hesitate to kill Cops, Judges, Jurors, Prosecutors, or Federal Agents either. Tommy Pitera is tough-as-nails, and completely fearless as well, he preys on the strong, he was known for killing huge men with the use of karate and other martial arts skills, just to make a point. He once beat 3 Hells Angel's MC members to death with his bear hands. He also once bombed a Hells Angels MC clubhouse. In my opinion Thomas Pitera is considered by me as one of the most evil people in history. During his 11 year period, as a made man in the Bonanno Crime Family, Tommy Pitera was one of the most feared men in New York City, he was also one of the most dangerous mobsters in America."
Born in New York City, Pitera grew up in the Gravesend section of Brooklyn to parents Joseph Pitera and Catherine. His father was a wholesale candy distributor salesman. Thomas had thick, jet-black hair with piercing blue-gray eyes and high cheekbones. He allegedly had a particularly high pitched effeminate falsetto voice that was compared by biographer Philip Carlo to Michael Jackson's but having even more falsetto. Mob associate turned informant Frank Gangi thought Pitera sounded more like Mickey Mouse or Minnie Mouse. This however is contradicted by DEA Agents who hunted Pitera, and likened his voice and mannerisms to Richard Widmark's character Tommy Udo, in the 1947 film Kiss of Death. Pitera was a quiet child who was bullied in school. He attended David A. Boody Junior High School in Gravesend, Brooklyn and left little impression with his teachers.
As a child, Pitera was a huge fan of the 1966 The Green Hornet television show and actor Bruce Lee; this began his lifelong interest in martial arts. Pitera was highly skilled in martial arts, having spent 27 months training assiduously in Tokyo, Japan where he studied under the revered Hiroshi Masumi after winning an arduous kumite competition in Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn. He was trained to use the tonfa, nunchucks and katanas. While in Japan, he grew his hair down to his shoulders to adopt the Bruce Lee image.
After his scholarship ended, he sought work in a chopsticks factory to underwrite his stay and earn more money. This led him to acquire the nickname "Tommy Karate" by friends and mobsters. After returning from Japan, Pitera joined the Bonanno family and quickly earned a reputation for extreme violence, brutality and murder. Pitera was one of the most vicious and feared soldiers on the streets, amongst the likes of Anthony Mirra, Alphonse Indelicato, Frank Lino, Anthony Gaggi, Thomas Agro, Gregory Scarpa, Anthony "Gaspipe" Casso, Benjamin Ruggiero, Sammy Gravano, Joseph Massino, William Cutolo, Anthony Indelicato, Anthony Senter, Joseph Testa, Dominick Napolitano, Victor Amuso, and Roy DeMeo, who were brutal and ruthless mobsters and veteran contract killers. Pitera married Celeste Lipari, his longtime love and wanted to adopt his step daughter Nicole who was tall and beautiful just like Celeste. Pitera and Celeste attended martial arts classes together where they worked out on a regular basis.
Pitera belonged to a family faction headed by captains Alphonse "Sonny Red" Indelicato, Frank Lino, Dominick Trinchera and Phillip Giaccone. This group opposed the current leadership under boss Phillip Rastelli and his leading captains Joseph Massino and Dominick Napolitano. In 1981, Massino and Napolitano set up the murders of the three rival captains in a Gravenhurst, Brooklyn club owned by Salvatore Gravano and Eddie Garofalo. After their deaths, Massino made peace with the rest of the leaderless faction, including Pitera. Pitera was working for Anthony Indelicato, until Bruno became a drug addict and fled New York. During the 1980s Pitera became a made man of the Bonanno family. Pitera then worked for Anthony Spero who put him in Frank Lino's crew.
On August 29, 1988, Pitera allegedly ambushed Wilfred "Willie Boy" Johnson as he walked ahead to their car and shot him to death. Johnson had been a close associate of Gambino crime family boss John Gotti since the two of them had been petty burglars and thieves. Johnson had also had served as a driver to Gotti after Gotti became a made man and Captain with the Gambinos. In 1985, Gotti discovered that Johnson had been a government informant since 1966. Pitera murdered Johnson as a favor to Gotti. The hit had allegedly been delegated to Pitera and fellow gunman, Vincent "Kojak" Giattino, by Gambino Capo Edward Lino. Pitera was charged with the Johnson murder, and acquitted at trial.
Pitera was close to Bonanno Consigliere Anthony Spero, who headed the violent Bath Beach crew. This group was involved in extortion, loan sharking, drug dealing and murders. Pitera's crew was notorious for robbing drug dealers and then reselling their drugs. Pitera murdered two Colombian drug kingpins and then resold their 40 pounds of cocaine. Pitera killed Tala Siksik, a Middle-Eastern drug supplier, in his Brooklyn apartment. Pitera stripped the body, then stripped himself naked and put the body in the bathtub. He then got into the bathtub with the body and sliced it into six pieces, and then buried it at a secret dumping ground. Investigators eventually found six of Pitera's victims in a mob graveyard in Staten Island near the William T. Davis Wildlife Refuge. Pitera had decapitated the bodies and buried the heads separately to impede their identification using dental records.
Pitera's approach to murder and body disposal was cold-hearted and clinical. He used the Staten Island graveyard because he believed that the damp soil would accelerate decomposition. Pitera studied books on dissection and carried a special tool kit for cutting up bodies. He always insisted on burying corpses deep enough so that police dogs could not locate their scents. Before burying body parts, Pitera either wrapped them in plastic or placed them in suitcases. Pitera's weakness was that he enjoyed keeping jewelry and other souvenirs of his work. This went beyond Mafia culture and was classic serial killer behavior.
On June 4, 1990, Pitera was indicted for heading a drug dealing crew and for his involvement in seven murders, including the 1988 Johnson murder. Investigators alleged that Pitera had been involved in as many as 60 or more murders. Pitera's crew sold about 220 pounds of cocaine per year, multiple kilos of heroin and hundreds of pounds of marijuana. FBI agents discovered more than 60 automatic weapons, knives, swords, and literature such as The Hitman's Handbook and Kill or Be Killed, which dealt primarily with assassination techniques as well as torturing and dismembering cadavers, in Pitera's apartment in Gravesend, Brooklyn.
One of Pitera's crew members, Frank Gangi, the nephew of Genovese crime family Captain Rosario Gangi, decided to testify against Pitera. Frank had been arrested for driving under the influence and allegedly started reliving Pitera's worst atrocities in his mind while sitting in the holding cell. Gangi confessed to all the murders he was involved in with Pitera, and provided information on other Pitera murders. Gangi described how Pitera matter-of-factly assassinated Gangi's girlfriend Phyllis Burdi while she was passed out in bed after sharing cocaine and sex with Gangi. Pitera then cut Burdi's corpse into six pieces in the bathroom. Gangi also testified that during a fight with a drug dealer named Marek Kucharsky, Pitera pulled a knife and repeatedly stabbed Kucharsky and finally cut his throat.
In Pitera's trial, the chief prosecutor, David W. Shapiro, demanded the death sentence for the "heinous, cruel and depraved" murders committed by Pitera. He called Pitera a "heartless and ruthless killer" explaining in detail how Pitera tortured one victim by slowly, deliberately shooting him seven times in various parts of the body, in one of a series of murders carried out in a deliberately barbaric manner. The prosecution also produced a Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) agent who testified to digging up graves containing the dismembered bodies of some of Pitera's victims.
Pitera's defense lawyer, David A. Ruhnke, urged the jury to reject the death penalty on the grounds that Pitera had no prior criminal record and that other participants in the murders were allowed to plead guilty to lesser charges. Moreover, only two of the murder victims, Richard Leone and Solomon Stern, were killed on March 15, 1989, after the Federal death penalty law went into effect. The four other murders took place earlier, so those counts carried maximum sentences of life in prison. Pitera's aunt, sister-in-law and two cousins testified on Pitera's defense that he was a loving and caring family member.
On June 25, 1992, Pitera was convicted of murdering six people and supervising a massive drug dealing operation in Brooklyn. However, Pitera was acquitted in the 1988 Wilfred Johnson murder. During the deliberation on sentencing, the jury rejected the death penalty for Pitera. In October 1992, alluding to evidence that Pitera brutally killed his victims and dismembered their bodies, Judge Reena Raggi sentenced him to life in prison, saying, "Mr. Pitera, nobody deserves to die as these people died."
After the verdict was read, Pitera smiled and gave a thumbs up to reporters sitting in the Brooklyn courtroom; he had avoided the death penalty. However, Pitera was irritated that Gangi was petitioning Judge Raggi for a reduction of his 10 year prison sentence. As Pitera later remarked,
"Gangi said he was sorry about killing five people and that he became an informer because he wanted to start a new life. He gets 10 years, a good deal, and he goes whimpering and weeping to the judge looking for a break. If you're really sorry for killing five people, you take your punishment like a man."
Later in 1992, Judge Raggi again refused a motion to reduce Gangi's sentence. On April 3, 2012, the U.S. Second Circuit Court of Appeals denied Pitera's motion for DNA testing of the guns and other evidence in three of Pitera's murders. As of April 2012, Pitera is serving a life sentence at the Federal Correctional Complex, Allenwood, in Pennsylvania. Pitera's inmate number is 29465-053.